Exclusive Beta Launch — Free for a limited time.

Breaking the Overthinking Spiral

By Mandy Morris
February 7, 2025
Back to Resources
Breaking the Overthinking Spiral

Have you ever replayed a conversation over and over, dissecting every word, tone, and pause, only to convince yourself you said the wrong thing? Or maybe your mind gets stuck on endless what ifs that have not actually happened. Overthinking can feel like you are trying to protect yourself, but it usually leaves you drained, tense, and more confused than when you started.

Overthinking is not a thinking problem. It is a nervous system problem. When your system feels unsettled or unsafe, your brain looks for certainty. It scans the past for mistakes and the future for threats, hoping that if it thinks long enough, it can prevent discomfort. The problem is that the answers rarely come, and the spiral keeps going.

For many people, overthinking started as a coping skill. At some point, staying alert, analyzing everything, or anticipating reactions may have helped you navigate uncertainty, conflict, or unpredictability. Your brain learned that thinking ahead was safer than being caught off guard. The challenge is that what once helped can quietly turn into a habit that keeps your body stuck in tension, even when there is no real danger in front of you.

How to break the cycle in the moment

1. Interrupt the loop. Overthinking keeps you stuck in your head. The fastest way out is through the body. Do something physical and simple. Stand up, stretch, take a few deep breaths, or change rooms. Even small movement signals to your brain that it is time to shift out of analysis mode. 2. Ask, “Is this a thought or a fact?” Overthinking feels convincing because the stories sound real. But many of them are guesses, not truths. Write it down if you need to. What do you actually know for sure, and what are you filling in because you feel anxious? Separating facts from assumptions can take the edge off quickly. 3. Create a short worry window. If your mind keeps pulling you back in, give it a boundary. Set a timer for five minutes and let yourself worry on purpose. When the time is up, redirect your attention to something else. This helps train your brain to recognize when it has gone far enough.

Overthinking thrives on the belief that more thinking will bring relief. Most of the time, it does the opposite. What actually helps is learning to tolerate not knowing, bringing your body back into the present moment, and taking small actions even when you feel uncertain. You are not failing because your mind spirals. Your system is trying to protect you. With practice and the right tools, it can learn that it does not have to work so hard.

If you notice yourself stuck in a mental loop, pause and bring your body back into the moment. Open the SoFree app and start a bilateral stimulation session to help your nervous system settle and break the spiral. Sometimes calm does not come from thinking your way out, but from letting your system reset.

Written by
Mandy Morris
LPC, Executive Coach, Certified EMDR Therapist